Six Attempts at the Top of the World — From Hudson's Doomed 1607 Voyage to the USS Nautilus Under the Ice
Muscovy Company, 1607 • The First English Attempt to Sail Over the Pole
In April 1607, the Muscovy Company sent Henry Hudson north in an 80-ton bark to find the open polar sea that scholars believed lay beyond the ice. He sailed up Greenland's east coast, doubled back to Spitsbergen, and pushed north until walls of ice barred further progress at about 80°23' N — a record for any European ship. He was looking for a route to Cathay over the top of the world. He returned in September with no passage, but his observations of whales in Spitsbergen waters started the British whaling industry. Four years later his crew would mutiny in his namesake bay and set him adrift to die.
c.1565–1611 • English sea-captain in service to England and the Netherlands
Hudson is one of the most consequential and least-known navigators in history. Backed first by the Muscovy Company, then the Dutch East India Company, then English merchants, he made four voyages in five years. He charted the river that bears his name (1609) and Hudson Bay (1610), each time looking for the same elusive northern passage. His own crew set him, his teenage son, and seven loyalists adrift in James Bay in June 1611. None were seen again.
London-chartered company seeking a northern trade route. Funded Hudson's first two voyages. Believed the Pole was an open sea surrounded by an "ice ring."
Hudson's mate. Sailed on three of his four voyages and is the chief suspect for instigating the 1611 mutiny in James Bay.
Henry's teenage son who sailed on all four voyages and was set adrift with his father. Their fate remains unknown.
English merchant whose 1527 letter to Henry VIII first proposed an Arctic route to Cathay. The polar sea theory derived from it underpinned Hudson's 1607 voyage.
Hudson belonged to the era when the geography of the Arctic was a theory. The "open polar sea" hypothesis — ice-free water around the Pole, surrounded by a barrier of pack ice — would not finally die until Nansen's Fram drift confirmed the polar basin's true nature in the 1890s. Hudson's 80°23' was a brave probe at the southern edge of the unknown.
Royal Navy, 1827 • The First Sledge Expedition Toward the Pole
Sir William Edward Parry, already famous for his Northwest Passage expedition of 1819–20 that wintered farther north than any ship had wintered before, decided in 1827 to try for the Pole itself. He proposed leaving HMS Hecla at Spitsbergen and travelling overland to 90° N with two specially-built reindeer-skin-shod sledge-boats. His logic was sound; the ice was not. The pack drifted south as fast as his men hauled north. After 61 days they reached 82°45' N — a record that stood for forty-eight years — and turned back.
1790–1855 • Royal Navy officer, Arctic veteran
Parry was the most experienced Arctic commander of his age. His 1819–20 expedition through Lancaster Sound had reached 110° W, halfway through the Northwest Passage, and his men had wintered at Melville Island in good health thanks to scrupulous antiscorbutic discipline. The 1827 sledge-boat attempt was intended to be the climax of his polar career; instead it was its end. He never went north again.
Parry's second-in-command at age 27. Future discoverer of the magnetic North Pole (1831), commander of the great Antarctic expedition (1839–43). Nephew of John Ross.
Specially built by Mr Wells of Blackwall: 20 ft long, oak-framed, with iron runners, reindeer-skin sleeves, and steel-shod hauling poles. Each weighed about half a ton empty.
Second Secretary of the Admiralty whose obsession with the Northwest Passage and the Pole drove dozens of expeditions in the 1820s and 1830s.
Royal Navy officer who would beat Parry's record by just 65 km on April 12, 1876, with the Nares Expedition — an 11-man scurvy-ridden sledge crawl out of Floeberg Beach.
Parry's expedition was the first to discover the brutal physics of polar travel: the ice itself moves, often faster than humans can walk against it. Nansen's Fram would later turn that fact into a strategy — let the ice carry the ship rather than fighting it. Parry's failure to do so was a half-century of frustrating polar progress in microcosm.
Norwegian Arctic, 1893–1896 • The Theory That Carried a Ship Across the Top of the World
Fridtjof Nansen, a Norwegian zoologist who in 1888 had made the first ski crossing of Greenland, designed a uniquely round-bottomed wooden ship that would be lifted up by pack ice rather than crushed. He sailed it deliberately into the ice north of Siberia in 1893 to test his theory that a transpolar current would carry it across the top of the world. The drift took longer than expected and missed the Pole. So in March 1895 Nansen and stoker Hjalmar Johansen left the Fram on skis with sledges, kayaks and dogs, and pushed north on foot to 86°14' N — a world record by 270 km — before turning for home.
1861–1930 • Zoologist, oceanographer, statesman, Nobel laureate
Norway's greatest scientist-explorer of the era. After Greenland and the Fram, he turned to oceanography (designing the Nansen bottle for sampling at depth) and then to humanitarian work. He organised the post-WWI repatriation of 450,000 prisoners of war and won the 1922 Nobel Peace Prize for the "Nansen passport" that gave stateless refugees legal status.
Captain of the Fram after Nansen left. Brought all 12 remaining men and the ship safely home. Later led his own four-year Canadian Arctic expedition mapping over 250,000 km².
Stoker who skied to 86°14' N with Nansen. Later joined Amundsen's South Pole expedition but was sent home in disgrace. Killed himself in 1913.
Norwegian-Scottish naval architect who designed the Fram. Her hull shape allowed ice to lift rather than crush her — the breakthrough that made the drift possible.
British explorer leading the Jackson–Harmsworth Expedition to Franz Josef Land. The astonishing chance of his meeting Nansen on Cape Flora is one of polar history's miracles.
Nansen reframed the polar problem. Instead of fighting the ice, he made it his vehicle. His success made the ski, the dog team, and the Fram the new orthodoxy of polar travel and prepared Amundsen's South Pole victory fifteen years later. The North Pole itself, however, remained unreached — and Nansen was content not to be the man who reached it.
United States, 1908–1909 • Two Americans, Two Claims, One Pole
On September 1, 1909, Frederick Cook returned from the Arctic and announced that he had reached the North Pole on April 21, 1908. Five days later, Robert Peary returned and announced that he had reached the Pole on April 6, 1909, and that Cook was a fraud. The resulting scandal — the "Polar Controversy" — consumed the popular press for years. Peary was officially endorsed by the National Geographic Society and the U.S. Congress. Cook was convicted of mail fraud in 1923. Modern scholars consider Cook's claim almost certainly fabricated and Peary's claim probably exaggerated; neither man's navigation can be fully verified.
Peary 1856–1920 • Cook 1865–1940
Peary, a U.S. Navy civil engineer, had spent 23 years pushing systematically northward from northern Greenland. Cook, a physician, had been Peary's expedition doctor in 1891 and had separately claimed the first ascent of Mount McKinley in 1906 (now known to be false). Their bitter rivalry went back fifteen years; the 1909 dispute was its grim climax.
African-American assistant who served Peary on every expedition for 22 years. Spoke fluent Inuktitut and built the sledges. Almost certainly stepped farthest north of any in the 1909 party.
Newfoundland sea-captain who skippered the Roosevelt. Turned back at 87°47' N on Peary's orders, leaving Peary, Henson, and the Inughuit to make the final dash.
Four Inughuit men who hauled, drove dogs, and built igloos for the final dash. Their geographic knowledge made the journey possible. They received almost no public credit.
British polar explorer who led the first surface crossing of the Arctic Ocean in 1968–69 and later wrote the most damning forensic analysis of Peary's navigation logs.
The Peary–Cook controversy crystallised the new role of media in exploration. Newspaper telegrams and lecture circuits made or broke reputations long before scholarly verification. The episode exposed the unreliability of unsupported polar claims and led directly to the standard later imposed of independent verification, sextants checked by witnesses, and corroborating photography.
United States Navy, 1926 • A Disputed Aerial Claim
On May 9, 1926, U.S. Navy Lt. Cdr. Richard E. Byrd and his pilot Floyd Bennett took off from Spitsbergen in a Fokker F.VII trimotor named Josephine Ford, claiming to fly to the North Pole and back in fifteen hours and fifty-one minutes. They were greeted as heroes; Byrd was awarded the Medal of Honor. But the flight time was barely sufficient and skeptics noted issues with the sextant log and oil leak. In 1996, Byrd's diary was made public and seemed to show calculations corrected after the fact. Most modern aviation historians believe Byrd turned back roughly 80 miles short. Three days later, Roald Amundsen's airship Norge made the first uncontested transit of the Pole.
Byrd 1888–1957 • Bennett 1890–1928
Byrd was a Virginia-born Naval Academy graduate who had championed long-range naval aviation. Bennett was a former enlisted aviation machinist's mate from upstate New York whom Byrd had personally chosen. Both received the Medal of Honor for the 1926 flight. Bennett died of pneumonia in 1928 on his way to Greenland to rescue downed airmen; Byrd lived to lead five Antarctic expeditions and become America's most public polar figure.
South Pole conqueror who came to Spitsbergen for the airship transit. Embraced Byrd in public but privately distrusted the flight. The two men remained outwardly cordial until Amundsen's 1928 disappearance.
Italian aeronautical engineer who designed and piloted the Norge. Argued for years that he, not Amundsen, deserved primary credit. Crashed the Italia in 1928, the rescue mission for which killed Amundsen.
Heir to the Ford Motor Company, who funded the Fokker and named her Josephine Ford after his three-year-old daughter. The plane is preserved at the Henry Ford Museum.
Astronomer and historian whose forensic analyses since the 1970s have made the strongest case that Byrd faked the flight, citing inconsistencies between his diary and official report.
The Byrd claim mirrored Peary's a generation earlier: a single-witness, single-instrument navigation record presented as definitive. The pattern broke only with the Norge: a multinational crew, multiple navigators, an officially-reported flight path, and an arrival at Teller, Alaska. From 1926 onward, polar claims required corroboration to be taken seriously.
U.S. Navy, August 1958 • The First Transit of the Pole Beneath the Ice
On August 3, 1958, at 23:15 Eastern Daylight Time, USS Nautilus (SSN-571) became the first ship of any kind to reach the geographic North Pole. She did it submerged, beneath the ice, under nuclear power, on a top-secret Cold War mission code-named Operation Sunshine. President Eisenhower had personally authorised it as both a polar first and a strategic demonstration: that ballistic-missile submarines could now lurk beneath the Arctic ice cap. The 116-man crew, under Commander William R. Anderson, transited the Pole at a depth of 122 m, sailing from the Pacific to the Atlantic in 96 hours. None doubted the navigation.
1921–2007 • Commanding Officer, USS Nautilus
Anderson was a Tennessee-born submariner who had served in eleven WWII war patrols. He took command of Nautilus in 1957 and personally proposed the polar transit to Admiral Hyman Rickover, the founding genius of the U.S. nuclear navy. Anderson later served four terms in Congress as a Tennessee Democrat.
The "Father of the Nuclear Navy." Personally interviewed every nuclear officer for 40 years. Pushed Nautilus from concept to sea in nine years against Pentagon opposition.
Anderson's executive officer who managed the inertial navigator and the under-ice sonar profile. The new gyrocompass technology was rebuilt to function within fractions of a degree of latitude near the Pole.
Personally authorised Operation Sunshine and announced the transit to the world. The Cold War demonstration was timed to follow the Soviet Union's Sputnik successes of 1957.
SSN-578, the second nuclear submarine. In March 1959, Skate became the first submarine to surface at the North Pole through thin ice, scattering Sir Hubert Wilkins's ashes there per his will.
Nautilus closed the polar age. After 351 years of surface attempts — from Hudson at 80° to Peary's disputed dash — nuclear power simply went underneath the question. The geographic North Pole became, for the first time in history, an unambiguously visited point on the Earth's surface, even if visited by sailors who could not see it. The ice cap above remained unconquered by foot until Wally Herbert's surface crossing of 1968–69.
| Expedition | Year | Method | Highest Point | Personnel | Verified? | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hudson | 1607 | Ship (sail) | 80°23' N | 11 men | Yes | Returned |
| Parry | 1827 | Boat-sledge | 82°45' N | 27 men | Yes | Returned |
| Nansen | 1893–1896 | Drift + ski | 86°14' N | 13 men | Yes | All Returned |
| Cook / Peary | 1908–1909 | Dog sledge | 90° N (claimed) | Cook + 2 / Peary + 5 | No | Disputed |
| Byrd-Bennett | 1926 | Trimotor flight | 90° N (claimed) | 2 aircrew | No | Doubted |
| USS Nautilus | 1958 | Nuclear submarine | 90° N (122 m depth) | 116 crew | Yes | First Confirmed |
From Hudson in 1607 to Nansen in 1895, every European attempt to reach the Pole failed. Three hundred years of voyages produced 5° of latitude (80° to 86°). The ice itself, drifting south, defeated every northward-pulling effort.
Nansen's Fram changed everything. By making the ice the vehicle rather than the obstacle, he reframed Arctic travel and opened the way for Amundsen's 1926 airship transit and ultimately Nautilus's 1958 under-ice run.
The 1908–1926 window produced five disputed Pole "firsts" (Cook, Peary, Byrd-Bennett, and others). Single-witness sextant logs, no corroborating photography, and intense press competition combined to leave the matter forever unresolved.
Every successful Arctic journey of the 19th and early 20th centuries depended on Inughuit and Inuit knowledge: dog teams, igloo construction, fur clothing, and route knowledge. Public credit went to Peary, Cook, or Nansen; the actual fieldwork was largely done by people whose names rarely appear in the official accounts.
What three centuries of human muscle could not do, nuclear propulsion did in 96 hours. Nautilus's under-ice transit ended the polar question by sidestepping it. After 1958 the geography was settled; only the politics — Soviet, American, Canadian sovereignty claims — remained.
Every polar attempt was less about geography than national symbolism: English maritime supremacy (Hudson), Royal Navy prestige (Parry), Norwegian independence (Nansen), American Cold War demonstration (Nautilus). The Pole's value was always ideological.
Drag to pan • Scroll to zoom • Hover for details